Cody Rhodes defeats Gunther after referee misses rope break at WWE Clash in Italy

Controversial arbitrations are clearly not limited to the NFL or NBA.

The WWE Undisputed Championship match between Cody Rhodes and Gunther on Sunday at Clash in Italy was also hit by a shaky decision from referee Dan Engler.

ZERO BS. JUST DAKICH. TAKE THE DON’T @ ME PODCAST ON THE ROAD. DOWNLOAD NOW!

Rhodes and Gunther were in the middle of a fast-paced finish to the match. The “American Nightmare” hit Gunther with a second Cross Rhodes, landing Gunther near the ropes. Rhodes pinned Gunther and the referee began his count. The broadcast showed Gunther’s foot under the ropes, which should have broken the count.

However, Engler wasn’t looking at Gunther’s legs because he mattered to Rhodes. The defending champion held Gunther’s shoulders down for the three count, stunning Gunther. “The Ring General” exited the ring and continued to signal to Engler that his foot was under the rope.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE SPORTS COVERAGE ON PK Press Club

A WWE wrestler performs during Clash in Italy at Inalpi Arena in Torino di Sangro, Italy on May 31, 2026. (WWE)

Rhodes celebrated with the crowd at Turin’s Inalpi Arena, while Gunther walked up the entrance ramp in anger. Rhodes remained champion, making his second title defense since winning the belt from Drew McIntyre earlier in the month.

Gunther earned the title shot after defeating Royce Keys two weeks ago. He initially refused to sign the contract for Clash in Italy before Keys was about to seize the opportunity.

Gunther has since made a point of reminding Rhodes that he used to make “Friday Night SmackDown” all about him. But now Gunther has a legitimate grievance about how his title match went.

A wrestler performs during Clash in Italy at Inalpi Arena in Torino di Sangro, Italy on May 31, 2026. (WWE)

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE PK Press Club APP

It is unclear how long Gunther will have to wait for another chance at the title.