- Only 3% of participants with access to AI were willing to say “I don’t know”
- Participants did not sufficiently question AI-generated insights
- “AI…eliminated participants’ willingness to suspend judgment”
A new study by researchers at French and Italian universities claims that humans struggle to compete with artificial intelligence when it comes to critical thinking.
According to the data, participants with access to AI were less likely to say “I don’t know,” with only 3% unsure about an answer requiring critical thinking, compared to 44% of participants without access to AI.
The study ultimately concludes that humans rely too heavily on artificial intelligence to replace potentially correct personal judgments with incorrect AI suggestions.
Does AI harm our critical thinking?
The study deliberately used a model with a lower accuracy rate to produce incorrect results, and yet humans still chose to use those results rather than think for themselves, come up with a more correct answer, or simply say “I don’t know.”
But despite this reliance on AI, human participants still seemed to recognize that the AI could be wrong. With small financial incentives to be more honest, more participants were less likely to follow AI’s words exactly.
“In five experiments, simply accessing the AI’s guidance nearly eliminated participants’ willingness to suspend judgment,” they wrote.
“As AI-generated responses become ubiquitous and, increasingly, unsolicited, our results show that the willingness to say ‘I don’t know’ could be one of the first casualties of human-AI interaction.”
The paper also reveals a related paradox that humans are more likely to feel confident in their responses when they have access to external information, whether AI-generated, even if it is not correct or completely relevant to their thought process.
While acknowledging many limitations and the small scope of this study, the researchers still call for more AI knowledge and education when it comes to verifying the findings and reinforcing the importance of human critical thinking.
Via The register
Follow TechRadar on Google News And add us as your favorite source to get our news, reviews and expert opinions in your feeds.
